Battling Pirates: Guns on Yachts?

Aug 29th 08
By Capt. Hugo, M/Y IF

I was anchored in Porto Vecchio in Corsica four nights ago, 100 meters astern of S/Y Tiara [Editor's Note: See "Pirate Attack Tarnishes Tiara"]. I considered this to be the safest place in the Med after their ordeal the previous night.

I’d like to share my experience on the matter of guns on boats.

To date I have had four separate incidents involving undesirables either aboard or trying to get aboard (aka modern-day pirate attacks).

Once whilst running from Hong Kong to Singapore off the Vietnam coast I was called to the bridge when a target was seen ahead of our Benetti Classic.

As the distance decreased, the target unlit moved off to our starboard side and in the darkness paralleled our course falling behind into our wake.

I had already set the yacht up in Hong Kong for such an event by blacking out all interior lights, so with the flick of the nav light switch I could go completely blackout.

I then changed my course 90 degrees in the hope that the now closing vessel astern wouldn’t have radar and would lose us in the darkness.

This was the case and as we now closed the Vietnam coast the offending vessel continued along the old course line. We lost them in the darkness.

Whilst cruising Burma about 13 years ago, and whilst anchored in a secluded bay with guests aboard, I was summoned to the aft deck of the 36-meter motor yacht I was captain of at the time.

The sight of young men armed to the teeth with machine guns sent the fear of God through me. I approached them, staying as calm as possible, and having sent the girls below on strict instructions not to be seen. I weyed deeply in the traditional Asian manner of respect (who wouldn’t with large caliber machine guns pointing at you)?

Quietly, but confidently, I told the boarders that I had a baby aboard and asked them not to harm any of us and that I would give them anything they wanted.

Speaking Thai directly to them, they were a bit surprised as they understood me and proceeded to give my Thai crew instructions on what they wanted: Food, beer, Coca-Cola, watches (fakes bought in Thailand just for such an occasion), and engine parts.

All this time the guests were kept out of sight and although we had several guns aboard they were no match for the machine guns, so I decided not to provoke an attack and keep the situation calm.

There was some shouting at my Thai crew and aggressive gestures with the guns, but somehow I never really believed they would start shooting, They looked more scared than I did.

Eventually they climbed aboard their long tail boat with the goodies and disappeared over the horizon.

 

South of Sri Lanka 150 nautical miles, a small boat with about five males tried to close on our yacht. I was alerted when they were a long way off so had a lot of time to weigh-up the situation. No fishing nets, boat not damaged, engine running well. I had a crew of two girls and three guys. The odds were not great if these guys had bad intentions.

What I noticed was that they were wearing long coats, and in the heat of the day this was for sure not right. I will never know what they might have had under the coats, machetes or some other weapons, and I wasn’t about to find out.

Hammers down and we were off like a bullet directly away from them. With enough speed to lose them I was happy with the decision not to hang around. The guns aboard stayed in the gun locker.

I was running aid from Lankawi, Malaysia to Banda Aeche after that terrible disaster [tsunami] on Boxing Day 2005. I had chartered local fast ferries to shuttle volunteers and supplies to the areas of Northern Sumatra devastated by the the tsunami.


Now one would think when engaged in “good work,” and flying the red cross as a sign of the good work we were doing, we would be safe. After several weeks of our efforts I was returning as normal, having dropped aid to our base on Paula Whey and Paro on the west coast of Sumatra. I normally kept the captain company as we passed through the channel of islands just off Banda Aeche’s newly shaped coastline.

At a distance of about five nautical miles offshore we noticed that what looked like fishing boats were forming a blocking maneuver directly across our course. Four boats were jockeying into a position, which was meant to stop us. We were now empty of our precious cargo of food and clothes, which meant we had our full speed potential of around 25 knots.

The captain looked at me, and I at him, and without a word from me the captain swung his vessel directly toward the outermost boat and at full speed was intent on cutting him in half. The fishing boat, realizing what was happening, quickly decided to give way and clear the course.

We made a fast, long turn to port and back in shore towards Banda Aeche where we met up with an Indonesian patrol boat. After explaining what had happened they escorted us out of Indo waters.

My view is stay vigilant; keep a good look out when in notorious areas. Have a plan, keep calm, run away if possible and keep the guns for the professionals.

 

What do you think? Should yacht captains carry guns to protect their guests and crew from pirate attacks? Let us know: leave your comments below.

 

For more on this controversial issue, please revisit our earlier DOCKWALK.com Hot Topic, "Should Captains Carry Guns?"

 

 

 






Rating  Average 3 out of 5

4 Comments
  • Unfortunately only the living can post on here.
    My opinion is that if you take your ship and crew into a risky area you should be prepared.
    A good 50 cal with a variety of ammo is a great deterrent out to about 1000m.
    Posted by Colin_4 27/07/2010 16:45:15

  • I think a great idea would be for problematic areas and countries to adopt a decoy strategy. Purchase a network of armed and armored yachts to patrol these areas with trained military personell and advanced anti-ship weapondry. Simply pose as a luxury yacht and when attacked, come out guns blazing! Blow them out of the water. And to keep them guessing, exchange these boats with other problem areas in the world to avoid pirates becoming familiar with individual ships. A harsh deterent for sure, but wouldn't these idiots start to think twice, not really knowing who they are attacking out on the open sea?
    Posted by flyryguy1 20/12/2008 17:27:30

  • I'm a Former U.S. Marine, a Special Agent in the State of Florida and the Founder/CEO of a security consulting company called Hard Target Security Group (HTSG) www.htsecuritygroup.com. A portion of my company is geared towards the training of Captian's and their crew in the safe and tactical handling of weapons, and the techniques to avoid unwanted boarding's. In addition to training, I offer the sale of thermal imaging camera's and technology to supplement the vessels security plan. Many of the opinions I've read concerning this issue are correct to a degree. While there is some necessary training I would disagree that it is too exhaustive. HTSG can provide private consultation and training to enhance your vessel security plan with minimal time away from the vessel. For crime to occur there must be 2 things present. Opportunity and Motive. When at sea or at port in a luxury yacht opportunity is great and motive is greater. What is worse is that the criminals risk is minimal. If you study societies lacking in law and the ability to enforce the law you will find that security and protection become a personal and essential task. Families, the captian and crew should all err on the side of caution and firmly believe in Semper Paratus because each of these may fall victim to pirating. Many of you have experienced very scary situations and have come out alive. You have been lucky. Don't allow yourself to find comfort in your denial saying it won't happen to me or I can negotiate with them. Instead truly ask yourself if you and the crew are prepared for the worst. If the answer is anything but "yes" please feel free to contact me directly to discuss this further.
    Posted by HTSG 02/09/2008 20:54:50

  • I have the misfortune of dealing armed bandits. They stole everything they could including the boat I was on at the time. The circumstances were very different to the normal yachting environment but the fact remains that no matter how I look at it being armed would not have helped my situation. I am alive to talk about and absolutely sure that if you carry a gun of any sort you must have the skill to use it. You must also realise that by showing that you are armed you may change the opinion of an armed robber from seeing you as a soft target to seeing you as a threat. In doing so it might encourage the baddies to use more force than they otherwise would have done.

    Our first responsibility in yachting is the duty of care of our shipmates and guests and I would take some convincing that crew could be trained effectively to use force in this endeavour and reduce the great risk of coming face to face with an armed intruder.

    Guns are for professionals use only.
    Posted by Mike French 01/09/2008 23:07:59

Add Comment

Text Only 2000 character limit
Latest Features
27/03/2014 12:00:00 PM
The Rotation Revolution 
By Janine Ketterer
27/02/2014 12:35:00 PM
The Great Age Debate 
By Janine Ketterer
05/02/2014 03:35:00 PM
Understanding ObamaCare — Is it possible? 
By Janine Ketterer
12/01/2012 05:00:00 AM
Working It in Australia and New Zealand 
By Kara Murphy and Jackie Miller
10/01/2012 04:20:00 AM
Provisioning in Oz and New Zealand 
By Kara Murphy and Jeanette Tobin
View Archive

May’s edition is here! It’s exclusively available to Dockwalk.com members to view online or download. CLICK HERE TO READ  

DigiDWLilFrontPageMay2014